Page 1 of 1

Ban Appeal (Hazardous)

Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:49 pm
by King_of_Bongo
Warcraft III username: Hazardous
Realm: East
Situation: Banned for 7 days for unsharing crow
Why you should be unbanned:

Im hazardous and recently got banned for unsharing a crow. I would like to appeal the ban by saying that the other player kept trashtalking not only me but the entire team since the beginning of the game, proof of this is that the entire team tried to votekick him not once, but twice. So thats why he got unshared, he kept being a rude troll during the game, trashtalking and generally being abnoxious to all, so i decided it was best for the team to unshare him before he did any more harm to us, e.g. like destroying items. Even more proof of my argument is that a teammate (whom i dont know) already posted in the ban that he was being rude and deserved what happened to him. I hope you see this and watch the complete replay not only the time where i unshared him, since there is a reason why i did that. Thank you very much for your time, good day and good luck.
PD. sorry for my english, not my modern language.

Re: Ban Appeal (Hazardous)

Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 4:09 pm
by nabo.
Here is the relevant game chat: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 273517.w3g

I watched the game until you unshared the courier, lb was generally respectful and played fine. If you did not want to continue sharing, you could have simply bought him a crowed recipe to make things even. Maybe he was rude and both parties (your team vs lb) shit talked each other, but tat is irrelevant. Yes, there seems to be few votekicks on lb, but he did not do much bad to deserve those. Yes, he could have been more present in team fights, but it is also partially you guys' fault for not communicating effectively grouping up better as a team.

+

It seems he told you it was bannable, but I guess in your defense you did not believe someone you thought had a negative behaviour:

[spoiler=]28:13 / Allied) Optimization: i crowed for him
(28:15 / Allied) Optimization: and he removed
(28:18 / Allied) Optimization: control
(28:24 / Allied) Optimization: i didn't ask for crow
(28:26 / Allied) LuckyLoki: lets go forrest huntinh
(28:27 / Allied) CT_Fletcher: i would too if I were to share with you
(28:31 / Allied) Hazardous: ^
(28:32 / Allied) Optimization: idc
(28:34 / Allied) Optimization: its still banable
(28:37 / Allied) Optimization: if you dont buy them one back
(28:38 / Allied) Optimization: lol
(28:45) Optimization killed Hazardous
(28:48 / Allied) Optimization: i've been banned for doing it[/spoiler]

Re: Ban Appeal (Hazardous)

Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 4:26 pm
by King_of_Bongo
I just read the dota rules and your absolubtly right. Im sorry, specially to my teammate. I did unshare him the crow, but it was only out of frustration cause we kept teamfighting 4v5 while he afk or farmed and i felt it was costing us the game. But anyway, i shouldnt have done that and i apologize about it. I just read the rules that now I see i should have at least bought him a new crow recipe which i admit, i didnt do, but mainly because i didnt know i had to. I promise this wont happen again. Next time ill just buy my own recipe or at least buy my teammate one if i decide to unshare him =( At least now i know better.
Thank you for your fast response. Good day.

Re: Ban Appeal (Hazardous)

Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 4:31 pm
by King_of_Bongo
I would just like to say that today its 16 de septiembre and since im mexican, i have today my first free day in 2 weeks. Could you at least please unban me for today and then ban me again tomorrows?? I would really appreciate that and would mean a lot to me because lately i havent had much free time. Thanks.

Re: Ban Appeal (Hazardous)

Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 4:38 pm
by nabo.
@King_of_Bongo

Application of ban will not be changed. I will not make it so your banned tomorrow, but not today.

Considering your good ban history on accounts hazardous@useast and king_of_bongo@useast
+
You did not know the rules(excuse), but you have admitted your mistake and have learned the rules
+
You originally shared the courier out of good trust to your teammates, not because he requested it
+
The original ban seems to be somewhat harsh considering most simple unshare brqs are 2-3 days: search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=unshare&fid%5B%5D=24&start=10

I feel that you deserve some type of benefit of the doubt. I will believe that you are a busy working man and just trying to play some dota while your day off. With a heavy warning, your ban has been reduced to 2 hrs.

Happy gaming.